When Is The Best Time To Quit Working?


So you’re finally getting close to financial independence.  You’ve worked hard, you’ve saved, and you’ve invested as much as possible.  Instead of worrying about debt, you now worry about return on investment.

Perhaps your net-worth has broken one million dollars.  You’re starting to feel pretty wealthy, and thoughts of saying sayonara to that 50 hour a week job might be on your mind…

But hold on a moment — You might want to think this through carefully.  There are optimal times and sub-optimal times to exit employment.

 

The Boom And The Bust 

We all know markets boom, and bust.  It’s the natural order of normal working markets.  Like the ocean, the waves come in, and the waves go out…

If you’re like most people, the vast majority of your wealth is going to be tied up in a 401k plan (or other workplace saving plan).  Its value fluctuates daily depending on stock market movements.  This means your net worth is highly correlated to the stock market.

[Don’t let the fancy mathy words like “correlated” scare you…it just means the stock market and your net worth both change in value together at similar rates]

Most people get that itch to retire early when markets are at their peak (like right now).  The stock market has been booming and equity prices are at or near all time highs.  People feel wealthy right now, and consumer spending is good.

Guess what — It’s exactly the WRONG TIME to quit if you’ve recently become financially independent.

What we’re talking about here is called sequence risk (sometimes called sequence of returns risk).  In a few words — It’s not only the average rate of return that matters, but also when those returns arrive.

Why?  When the next major correction arrives, your net worth is going to take a big haircut.  In any single given year, stock prices can have huge swings between 52 week highs and the 52 week lows.  Swings of around 50% in fact.  You don’t want to be withdrawing capital during a 50% decline.

Think a 50% market drop is unrealistic?  Think again:  The Dow dropped more than 50% from its peak during the last U.S. recession.  From a historical perspective, market drops exceeding 20% are surprisingly common according to some studies.

Before you go tell the boss where he can shove his TPS reports, make certain your portfolio can survive that next big haircut!

So let’s run this little calculation right now, shall we…  Imagine you had a net worth of 1.2 million dollars in your 401k.  Now take that haircut, and mentally lose 50% of your net worth (to simulate a big market correction):

$1.2m X 50% = $600,000

How does that feel?  Not such a large sum anymore, is it?

If we use the 4% rule, that portfolio could generate around $24,000 in income.  Could you quit your job and live off that?

Admittedly, a 50% general stock market drop would be pretty bad, but that’s far from being a worst-case scenario.  The stock market dropped around 90% during the Great Depression, making our recent recession look small by comparison.

 

Where Are We Now?

At this point (late 2016) we’ve had 7 years of economic expansion, and rising stock market prices.  It’s been a very good run.  But how do we know if we’re at the top of the market, the bottom, or somewhere in the middle?

It’s really hard to say — we can’t predict the future.  The stock market could start dropping tomorrow, or we could still have years of economic expansion (and rising stock prices) ahead of us.  But the odds are against it.

No economic expansion in the United States has continued for more than a decade without a recession.  Statistically speaking, I think it’s safe to say that we’re either somewhere “in the middle” or near “the top”.

So how do we avoid sequence risk when we can’t tell the future?  I’ve collected a few strategies that might help solve this little conundrum…

Strategy #1 — The Margin of Safety 

Remember our 50% haircut calculation?  The simple act of doing that 50% calculation already has those mental wheels turning.  Suddenly you might be thinking “will I have enough when it happens?”

So, when to quit?  Frankly, you can quit at any time as long as you have a big enough margin of safety to deal with major market corrections.  After a 20% to 50% haircut, can you maintain your standard of living?

The idea with this strategy isn’t that we can avoid sequence risk, but you might be able to overcome the negative effects with just more savings.  Sequence risk doesn’t matter nearly as much when you have WAY more than you need.

If it looks like you don’t have enough to weather a 50% decline tomorrow, it would be prudent to build-up your margin of safety!  This advice may fall on deaf ears for those caught up in market exuberance.  Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

 

Strategy #2 — Save And Catch The Wave

That said, the absolute best time to quit a job would be after a recession ended and stock prices were rising again.  If you continue to work and invest your savings all through the decline, those funds would act like a tail wind as the market moved back into expansion….pushing your net worth higher.  With any luck, this would ensure sufficient income to live-off for a long period of time, and avoid sequence risk.

Catch The Wave
Catching The Wave: An example of the S&P 500 from the Great Recession time period. This illustrates catching the economic contraction and expansion market waves.

Think of this strategy as “catching a wave”.  Just a like a surfer wants to ride a wave all the way into shore, an investor needs to make the right moves to catch the market contraction and expansion wave — to carry him (or her) as far as possible.  That means avoiding any withdrawals from your portfolio during negative bear markets.  That would slow our momentum way too early.  We need to build up speed and set up a good sequence of returns!

So, diligently invest your savings when the market declines, and avoid any withdrawals.  Then, ride the economic expansion into retirement.

building up momentum
The most common way to avoid sequence risk is to build up enough momentum in the early years of retirement. This means achieving a string of good returns and not withdrawing during down markets.

 

Strategy #3 — Avoid Stock Market Correlated Assets

Another strategy I see frequently utilized is to move assets out of the stock market, and into uncorrelated assets.

Whether it’s bonds, real estate, or even private companies, the general idea is to move a big chunk of your assets into other markets that will be significantly less correlated to the stock market. (They are also frequently less liquid, so be careful)

When the stock market starts dropping, these kind of assets will either change price very slowly, or not at all in response to the stock market.  Uncorrelated assets can then sustain the investor while they wait out the recession.

Frequently these assets get criticized for their low returns compared to the stock market.  But in my experience, given enough effort, these kinds of assets can have returns as big as stocks.  It just takes more work.

In fact, some real estate investors go their entire lives without investing in the stock market.  I’ve known a few of them.  It’s very possible to do.  But it does take skill and a lot of work.  It isn’t nearly as easy as investing in index funds.

 

Strategy #4 — Income, Not Net Worth

Another way to think about how to solve this problem, is to ignore net worth completely.  Stop looking at whatever the market quotes you daily and focus instead on the income your portfolio generates.

When the income from your stocks, bonds, preferred shares, REITs, real estate, and other assets exceeds your expenses, you can go tell-off the boss.  Again, some margin of safety is a good idea, but income generating investments tend to be fairly stable.

Why does this avoid the sequence of returns problem?  When you live off the income only, you don’t need to sell when markets are down….deftly avoiding sequence risk.

If you haven’t already guessed, this is the general strategy the Tako family has taken.  We’re attempting to live off only dividends in 2016.

We’ve built up our investment portfolio over the years to exceed $2 million dollars.  But I don’t even think about that number.  It can change daily, and I mostly ignore it (which is exactly why I don’t post about our net worth more frequently).  Instead, we focus on income, all the while maintaining steady growth.

 

Strategy #5 — Don’t Quit, Get Laid Off!

After your finances pass into the realm of financial independence, you may want to consider an alternative to quitting — Get yourself laid off!!  This is the ideal way to exit a job because of severance packages.

In most cases, if you’ve worked at a company for a significant number of years, they’ll provide a severance package…to..err… smooth the transition.  That severance package can help setup your financial independence (or early retirement) for success!

I had the opportunity to collect such a severance package at my last job, before I decided to be a “stay-at-home” dad.  I exited the job with a layoff, and it netted a decent severance package.

While it wasn’t intentional on my part to get laid off, I had a pretty good idea this was going to happen.

The company I worked for decided to close my local office.  At the time, employees were told that there would be no layoffs, and everyone would work from home.  Great story!  If only it had been true — one-by-one, over the last year every single employee was laid off!

Had I quit my job when I sensed the risk, I would have received absolutely nothing.  But hanging in there for a couple months until it was my turn, proved very beneficial.  I ended up with 4 months of extra living expenses, in cash!

So if you can, don’t quit!

Engineer your layoff when your finances are ready!  This could be as simple as getting yourself put onto a failing product that will eventually be canceled.  Sometimes you can even volunteer to be laid off!

Other times, you’ll need to take a more direct approach — maybe you forget to file those TPS reports, or constantly come into work late.  Office Space (a fantastic movie btw!) provides some excellent examples on how to achieve this feat.

 

Conclusion

I hope you find this set of strategies useful.  Can you think of any I missed?

Sequence risk is real, and it’s absolutely imperative for anyone who’s recently achieved financial independence to build up enough momentum early-on.

Escaping the negative returns isn’t easy when we can’t predict the future.  But having a smart strategy to avoid the problem probably won’t hurt!

When that big wave finally comes crashing down…make sure to be well out of the way.

[Image Credit: Flickr1, Flickr2]

21 thoughts on “When Is The Best Time To Quit Working?

  • October 22, 2016 at 5:44 AM
    Permalink

    Good point! I would have liked to go through one more recession before quitting, but the market keeps going up and there is no easy way of telling when it will give. What made the decision easier for me was having backup plans in addition to a portfolio. Mrs CK has a retirement job she enjoys, and if I want more cash I have the option of doing some consulting.

    Reply
  • October 22, 2016 at 6:43 AM
    Permalink

    Just…. finishing… the last….TPS report…. whew! ok now I can comment. Hilarious post as usual. I’m glad I got the memo about the new TPS report. Ok I need stop with the quotes.

    Interesting take on the stock market. I see a lot of people in the camp of “hey this is getting too high – it’s been rising too long” but has it? I feel like since 2008 we’ve just been going up and down with no real direction. I haven’t seen a big expansion like in the ’90s. So I think we’re actually ready for lift off.

    But I would say, “what about hedging?” So why not go out and get some S&P 500 futures to hedge your portfolio. This would enhance the strategy of using uncorrelated assets. Mainly because there is a perfect negative correlation 🙂

    Great post again – good luck on getting through the next major stock market decline which will certainly come – eventually.

    Reply
    • October 23, 2016 at 10:31 AM
      Permalink

      Hedging could work…if you knew what was going to happen. It could also be a waste of money too!

      Reply
    • October 27, 2016 at 3:50 PM
      Permalink

      Yeah, PatientWealth, I’m gonna go ahead and ask you to come to the office on Saturday. Those TPS reports are not gonna fill themselves, you know?

      Reply
      • October 27, 2016 at 5:56 PM
        Permalink

        Umm yeah – I’m also going to need you to come in on Sunday. See we’ve lost a couple people and we’re sort of … playing catch up.

        Sounds like someone’s got a case of the Mondays!

        Reply
  • October 22, 2016 at 9:25 AM
    Permalink

    While not a great reason to stick around a job that is detrimental to your well being, including mental health, be sure to consider year end or Q1 bonuses, and vesting schedules of other benefits. If you have worked for that bonus for 10 months, and the situation is agreeable, get the money you deserve. 🙂

    Reply
  • October 22, 2016 at 5:52 PM
    Permalink

    I’ve identified the ideal time to quit. It’s when the likelihood you’ll regret retiring too soon matches the likelihood you’ll regret working too long. http://www.physicianonfire.com/early-retirement-likelihood-regret/ Unfortunately, it can be awfully tough to identify on the fly.

    I finally figured out exactly when I will be fully vested in my employer’s contributions to my 401(k), so that’s the tentative date (Summer 2018). I’m anticipating working a bit in New Zealand after that, but for the experience, not the money.

    Great post! Cheers!
    -PoF

    Reply
    • October 22, 2016 at 8:20 PM
      Permalink

      Wow, Paris, Iceland, New Zealand…you do get around PoF!

      New Zealand is supposed to be pretty pricey from what I’ve heard! Enjoy it!

      Reply
  • October 23, 2016 at 8:53 AM
    Permalink

    Another strategy could be the willingness to be flexible. Since you can’t predict the market, you could retire when you hit your “number”, as long you understand the sequence of returns risk and are willing to take measures to adjust. If you are willing to step back into the workforce (maybe part time) to protect your nest egg, or if you are willing to temporarily relocate to a cheaper area when your portfolio receives a haircut, you could then deal with the problem when it occurs, and not have to work too many more years to pad your portfolio or wait for the next downturn. If you stubbornly decide to withdraw 4% no matter what you are probably going to end up being a very sad panda.

    Reply
    • October 25, 2016 at 10:58 PM
      Permalink

      Indeed, flexibility opens up many possibilities. This is exactly why I wondered if people could live on $600k *after* the big market haircut. Some could probably handle it, but many couldn’t!

      Reply
  • October 23, 2016 at 12:48 PM
    Permalink

    I like approach #3 as well that’s why we are working to have dividend income exceeding our expenses one day. #4 seems like a good plan as well, especially if you can somehow time it so it’s around the time you can call quit.

    Reply
  • October 24, 2016 at 8:10 AM
    Permalink

    This is exactly why I’d like Mrs. RB40 to retire after a recession/correction. I don’t want her to retire now because a lot of things can change very quickly. The market is sky high and our net worth could drop suddenly. Our passive income isn’t quite enough to cover our living expense yet so we’re relying on my online income too.
    I like relocating to a cheaper area for a few years too. However, that’s not a good option when our kid is in school. I guess he’ll survive, but I’d like to keep the disruption to the minimum. Our kid doesn’t handle changes very well right now.

    Reply
    • October 25, 2016 at 10:56 PM
      Permalink

      I think you guys are playing things pretty smart. Our plan is essentially the same as yours — invest through the next recession and then have Mrs. Tako finally retire when the market bounces back.

      Reply
  • October 25, 2016 at 7:44 AM
    Permalink

    I’ve been thinking about this topic a little more over the past few weeks and I’m truly hoping that I’m able to “catch a wave” when I hit my FI date. I really don’t want to work a day past it – in fact, I’d like to leave sooner than later! 😉

    The only thing I have going for me is that part of my plan includes having a handful of rental properties that will handle some of our expenses to help us out during that time. If the wave doesn’t hit at the right time, we’re going to have to re-evaluate to figure out the best exit strategy. Fingers crossed!

    — Jim

    Reply
  • October 27, 2016 at 1:26 PM
    Permalink

    I am essentially working on plan # 3 – Living off dividends in retirement.

    I want to live off the fruit from my portfolio, not cut off the tree that produces it.

    Reply
  • October 28, 2016 at 11:12 AM
    Permalink

    Ok, I agree, but how do you know that we are high right now? What if the market does continue to go up for another 7 years and you don’t want to wait that long before retiring?

    I think the key here is flexibility. I think that the 4% rule can greatly be expanded if one is ready to live on only 2% when the market tanks. We are ready to skip the vacation, eat more Tofu, Eggs and Beans if everything tanks 😛

    I like to look at it from the income point of view, great way to measure your wealth.

    Reply
    • November 2, 2016 at 12:53 PM
      Permalink

      I certainly have no idea what the market will do. Flexibility is definitely important, but what I was trying to point out is there’s multiple ways to skin that cat!

      Reply
  • November 1, 2016 at 3:58 AM
    Permalink

    Strategy #4 = YES! I hope more and more people spread the message to engineer their layoff. Negotiating a severance package is one of the best things that has happened to me. My final payment of my 2012 severance is hitting my bank account by 2Q2017 and then I’m finally done.

    Lock down as long a financial run way as possible b/c the transition can be stressful!

    Sam

    Reply
  • November 6, 2016 at 4:50 PM
    Permalink

    Waiting for your lay-off is always brilliant. Glad it worked out for you

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *