How To Be A Dividend King


Getting a big dividend check has to be one of the best parts about investing.  It’s certainly one of my favorites!  Nothing makes me feel more like a King than when the dividend checks come rolling in.

While I haven’t done a specific post on dividends yet, today’s the day!  People are usually amazed at the size of our dividend income when I report it every month.  

Last year our dividend income exceeded $100,000.  That was a pretty great year.  This year, our dividend income will be closer to $50k, which is still pretty significant.

Most financial independence bloggers don’t have this kind of dividend income, they mainly rely on capital appreciation — so I stand-out with my large ….. dividend income.  

(Did you think I was going to say tentacles?)

So why exactly is my dividend income so big?  Did I sacrifice quality in exchange for that income (with high yields, junk stocks, junk bonds, etc)?

 

The Tako Difference

One of the main differences between myself and other bloggers is my portfolio composition.  About 75% of our wealth is in two taxable portfolios, and the remaining 25% is in tax deferred accounts.  It wasn’t planned this way, but that’s just how life worked out.

Life hasn’t always been easy.  In my job history I didn’t always have access to a 401k plan.  

(Even when I did, that didn’t stop a company from raiding my 401k after I got laid off.  True story!  I lost around $25k in retirement funds after a layoff because a crappy 401k plan required 5 years of vesting before I owned a given year’s matching cash.  Aaarrrgh!)

The size of my tax deferred accounts ended up suffering because of this.  Life gave me lemons.  I made lemonade instead.

 We just kept saving as much as we could, and much of it ended up our taxable accounts.

Because the savings were in a taxable account, I had investing options other than mutual funds.  Stocks, bonds, preferred shares, REITS — all of these potential investments generate cash.  

Mutual funds typically are not big dividend payers — their dividends are frequently used for paying fund fees.  That’s right, those 1% fees when you invest in a mutual fund, your dividends end up paying those fees.

Index funds tend to be easier on the fees, but they usually hold so many stocks that the dividend yield ends up getting watered down by companies that don’t pay dividends (or only very small dividends).

I skipped these little problems, and focused on building a Dividend Growth portfolio instead.

 

Dividend Growth Investing (DGI)

Dividend Growth Investing is something of a holy grail for investors, especially those seeking financial independence.

The idea of receiving regular dividend payments from your investments is extremely appealing for someone who desires to live off passive income alone.  Even better, those dividend payments can grow faster than inflation, as the company continues to invest and improve the business.  This can lead to real wealth building if an investor holds on long enough.

Sounds pretty appealing doesn’t it?

There are a couple schools of thought around dividend growth investing:  Those who seek out high yield investments (which grow slowly) or low yielding investments that grow faster.

Why wouldn’t we pick high yield, high growth investments?

Great idea!  In an ideal world we could have both attributes.  But in reality both of those attributes are hard to find together.

 

Dividend Growth

Most businesses need cash to grow.  Machinery, stores, inventory, and so on.  They all take cash to grow.  In most types of business, the company with the most spare capital to invest should be able to grow the fastest.

But therein lies the problem — dividends compete for that same cash.  The business managers (CEO and board of directors) usually decide how much cash to pay out as dividends, and how much should be retained for growth projects.  They determine the payout ratio.

Those managers could choose to retain most of the cash for reinvesting in the business (or maybe just buy themselves that new corporate jet).  If that’s the case, a smaller chunk of cash is available for dividends.  This usually results in a lower payout ratio, but higher growth prospects.

The company could also choose to distribute most of the operating cash flow to shareholders in the form a large dividend.  Some kinds of companies (like REITs) even require it — but it also means very little cash is retained to grow the business.  

Can a high yielding company grow earnings enough to keep up with inflation?  Can they grow fast enough to build real wealth?

All good questions to answer before considering a higher yielding investment.

 

Which is Better?

Ultimately, the answer to this question is going to be pretty personalized.  Some people are going to fall into one camp (high growth), and others into the other camp (high yield).

Some investors are going to need high current income.  Maybe they didn’t save enough, but they still need income.  If that’s the case, higher-yielding investment often look attractive.

Other investors will limit income to minimize taxes.  Maybe they saved too much, and now generate too much income.  This kind of investor specifically picks stocks or mutual funds with lower yields (on purpose) to stay out of the higher tax brackets.  That’s a pretty “good problem” to have.

Whatever the case, high yield isn’t always the best course of action — Depending upon the starting yield and the rate of dividend growth, one would eventually expect the fastest grower to outgrow the ‘high-yield’ cousins.

But how long might that take?

Let consider a couple of different options:

  • Company A – The 2.5% yielding company.  She doesn’t pay out much, but she’s a fast grower.  Dividend growth is expected to grow annually at 10% a year.
  • Company B is something of a middle roader.  Sporting a 3.5% dividend yield, Company B still retains a big chunk of earnings for reinvestment (maybe 60% of earnings are retained).  This same company is expected to grow the dividend at a 7% rate.
  • Company C is our high yield option.  With a dividend yield of 4.5%, this company spits off significant cash flows as dividends.  Because Company C retains so little cash for reinvestment, they also are the slowest growing of the three companies.  A 5% growth rate is expected over the coming years.

Ok, those are our three hypothetical options.  Which option going to have the best dividend rate over time?  It’s easiest to consider the answer in the form of  graph:

Dividend Growth

As you can see, Company C, (our high yielder) did really well in the early years.  Only after year 12 does the dividend growth of Company A and B exceed that of Company C.  

Yes, 12 years!  That’s a long time to wait!!  .

When you think about that, it’s pretty incredible…At normal dividend growth rates, it would take decades of holding a “faster grower” before the income exceed that of the high yielder.  

This leads me to concluded that: Dividend Growth Investing is only for the extremely patient.

Growth can be a little overrated, especially if you don’t have decades to live.  Growth is a younger person’s game.

 

The Dangers of High Yield

Unfortunately, high yield investments have additional risks.  The earnings payout ratio of a ‘high yield’ investment is typically higher (sometimes 50% or higher).  This means a high yield investments are more likely to need a dividend-cut when the next recession finally rolls around.  High yielding companies are most susceptible to potential financial difficulties during recessions.

When the “shit hits the fan”, dividend cuts are often the solution.

Dividend cuts can be a big problem…especially if you need that cash to buy groceries, or pay the mortgage.  Anyone that depends on dividend income alone for living expenses will want to avoid these kinds of high yield/higher risk investments.

 

Finding The Middle Ground

For the Tako family, we seek out a “middle ground” between high and low yield options.  I look for investments with decent growth, a sub 50% payout ratio, and a dividend yield that roughly matches my withdrawal rate (we like a 3% withdrawal rate).

Why do I try to match my dividend yields with my withdrawal rate?  So I don’t need to sell stock to pay expenses, and I won’t generate too much income!  But there’s also a secondary advantage — lower yields and faster dividend growth rates.  

Eventually, all that money I don’t need today will grow into something much larger…I just have to wait a few decades.  Dividend growth investing definitely isn’t for the impatient.  

Thankfully, we don’t need a lot of cash to live a good life.  Our stated goal is to live off our dividends in 2016 (roughly 48k in dividends).  That’s a 3% withdrawal rate from our taxable portfolio alone.  We’re just letting our tax deferred accounts (401k’s and IRA’s) grow right now.

We should be in good shape for significant portfolio growth in the future.

 

Low Growth Environments

Currently much of the developed world is in what I call a “low growth environment”.  Earnings growth has been low to nonexistent for the last 5 quarters.  This doesn’t bode well for dividends either.  Some people say a recession is coming.

They could be right.

Dividends should really only grow when earnings are growing.  If earnings aren’t growing, and dividends are, that means the payout ratio is rising.  This can sap future growth and make a dividend investment riskier over time.  A perfect real-life example to illustrate this would be Telus, one of the companies in my portfolio.  

Telus is a big cell phone and internet provider in Canada.  One of the big three in Canada (oligopoly economics apply in this case).  Back when I originally invested in late 2011, the payout ratio was roughly 60% of earnings…higher than I normally look for.  But the dividend was growing fast.  Combine that with a growing, low risk business (cell phones and internet) — I figured it might work out great.  Boy was I wrong.

Fast forward 5 years and now payout ratios are closer to 70%.  Debt levels are significantly higher, and earnings growth has been minimal.  Check out the last few years of results:

YearEarnings Per Share (USD)Dividends (USD)Payout Ratio
2012$1.86$1.2366%
2013$1.89$1.2868%
2014$2.00$1.3266%
2015$1.67$1.2373%
TTM$1.81$1.3172%

What the hell happened?

Several things combined to ruin this potentially great investment.  Exchange rates between the Canadian dollar and the U.S. dollar ended up destroying most of my dividend growth, and now the payout ratio is in the 70%+ range.  Debt levels are higher too.  I consider this a failure.  It’s pretty safe to say that I’m thinking about selling this investment.

CADUSD
Value of the Canadian dollar vs the U.S. Dollar during the time of my Telus investment. It ended up killing my dividend growth.  (Foreign exchange numbers provided by Yahoo Finance.)

From my point of view, the dividend didn’t grow (even though it did in Canadian dollars), and now the company is in a worse financial state.  

The stock appreciated over 40% (in USD) since my purchase, and I received 5% in dividend income per year.  That’s a combined return of 65% over 5 years.  A mere 13% annually.  What a disaster!  

I’m going to hold my head down in shame.  Just give me a moment….

….

See folks, I share my failures too.  Not just the wins.  Not every investment ends up being a gigantic multi-bagger.  Sometimes you just have to accept 13% returns…or less.

I don’t really have any great secrets to solving the problems of this low growth environment.  I want to keep dividends growing, but finding earnings growth in this environment is hard.  

I’m looking for either large diversified companies that are growing internationally (because earnings are not growing at home folks!), OR a smaller company that’s growing earnings in a very profitable niche.

Returns on Capital need to be excellent in either case.

Either way, I hold one rule sacred when dividend growth investing:  The dividends must grow without deteriorating the financial strength of the company.

 

[Image Credit: UnprecedentedMediocrity]

22 thoughts on “How To Be A Dividend King

  • August 26, 2016 at 5:19 PM
    Permalink

    Great job on the dividend income!!! I am at ~$2K a month, and hope to be at $3K a month in 5 years when I turn 62. My rental income is well beyond $100K, so maybe that makes up for it.

    I mainly invest in IVV, DVY, IVW, QQQ and IWM. Nothing fancy. At this point, all dividends are reinvested.

    What are your main stocks or funds to get the dividends?

    Reply
    • August 26, 2016 at 9:37 PM
      Permalink

      We haven’t released a list of what makes up our full portfolio. I might choose to leak a few names every now and then, but prefer to keep the vast majority confidential.

      Reply
      • February 17, 2017 at 8:02 PM
        Permalink

        It’s good to be the king. Dividends can make young people rich down the road.

        Reply
  • August 26, 2016 at 7:44 PM
    Permalink

    Thanks for sharing this information about dividend investing. That’s amazing to pull in some much per year in dividend income!

    I’m also curious about what stocks or funds you invest in for dividend income. I’m a pretty normal index fund investor, with all of my portfolio in tax deferred accounts, but interesting to read about other styles of investing.

    Reply
    • August 26, 2016 at 9:34 PM
      Permalink

      We haven’t disclosed our full portfolio to the world yet, but I have let slip a few of them in various posts or comments on the site.

      Others, like the Well Known Energy Company, I’m definitely keeping quiet about for now.

      Reply
  • August 26, 2016 at 9:12 PM
    Permalink

    13% return a year is pretty sweet. Nice to see that you know when to sell as well.

    The low growth environment is tough but hopefully inflation remains low too as these tend to be connected. I like using higher yield stocks to generate cash flow for more investments but I too tend to have a mix of high and low dividend payers, that average to be about 3.2% per year at present.

    -Mike

    Reply
  • August 27, 2016 at 2:20 AM
    Permalink

    You should be seeing a rise in the Canadian dollar again compared to the US dollar. I just did an analysis on foreign currencies compared to the US dollar and foreign investors have played a significant rule in pushing the US markets to the highs we see today. Foreign investors won big with currency conversions to US dollars and with the US market increase. Now foreign investment money is moving out of the US markets and taking their money back home. We are already starting to see foreign currencies rise and the US dollar is starting its descent. Not sure if that will help your position but figured I would point it out!

    Reply
  • August 27, 2016 at 5:30 AM
    Permalink

    Lemonade? Sounds more like champagne!
    Most of our investments are in retirement accounts. Like you mentioned, we just go with the stock index funds to keep our taxable income down.
    It’s awesome that you made a great portfolio that grows and generates the income you need without any selling.

    Reply
  • August 27, 2016 at 9:01 AM
    Permalink

    Dividends are all fine and dandy when you’re early retired and living in a low tax bracket.

    On the other hand, if you are earning a good income, dividends are the worst. I’m taxed at about 30% on qualified dividends, higher on ordinary dividends. To me, a dividend is the equivalent of a forced stock sale. Fortunately, the index funds in my taxable account (which is more than half of the portfolio) dole out about 2% in mostly qualified dividends, creating a 0.6% tax drag. At a 3% dividend, my performance would suffer by 0.9%.

    I’m not one to buy individual stocks, but I bought some BRKB this month for the advantageous dividend payout, which is of course Zero.

    Best,
    -PoF

    Reply
    • August 27, 2016 at 10:52 AM
      Permalink

      Haha…advantageous dividend payout! 🙂 That’s a good one! You must be in a really high tax bracket to be paying 30% for qualified dividends!

      FYI – Most of Buffett’s stock purchases over the years have been dividend growth type companies. Nearly every single company pays a consistently growing dividend.

      Reply
      • August 29, 2016 at 2:16 PM
        Permalink

        15% federal LTCG / qualified dividends, 9.85% state income tax, 3.8% ACA surtax. It could easily 5% higher if I was in the top federal tax bracket, making the LTCG tax 20%.

        People tend to forget or don’t know that you generally have to pay full state income tax on capital gains and dividends. I think the ACA surtax is for MFJ over $250,000 income, or singles with income over $200,000.

        Best,
        -PoF

        Reply
        • August 29, 2016 at 3:32 PM
          Permalink

          Thankfully no income tax here in Washington state!

          Reply
  • August 27, 2016 at 12:10 PM
    Permalink

    Is dividend King higher than dividend president or emperor? Lol
    Congrats keep those dividends rolling

    I’ve been googling that well known energy company lol haven’t found it lol

    Reply
  • August 27, 2016 at 5:52 PM
    Permalink

    Great post. As PoF stated, dividend income is great if you are living in a low tax bracket, if your income are primarily in taxable accounts. But when your income is high, dividend income may not be the most tax efficient way to do thing. That’s why we try to maximize our tax free and tax deferred accounts first before investing in taxable accounts.

    Interesting that you mentioned Telus. We hold Telus in our portfolio as well, the EPS certainly isn’t growing as fast as dividend growth. Something to monitor. 🙂

    Reply
    • August 27, 2016 at 6:56 PM
      Permalink

      You’re certainly right Tawcan. If you have tax deferred accounts, that’s a great way to go. Many don’t/didn’t have that luxury. Please remember how fortunate you are. It could come across as insulting to those less fortunate.

      Many people, like myself, didn’t always have a choice.

      The most tax efficient way to do things is going to vary based on your own situation and local tax code. That’s why I stated in the post that it’s a personal decision. You and PoF fall on the side of minimizing taxes because you have incredibly large incomes.

      That’s a nice problem to have I guess.

      Reply
  • August 29, 2016 at 7:38 AM
    Permalink

    Wow, your stinker is a huge win. 🙂
    I don’t like very high yield either. There is usually something wrong with the company. Some people are betting their early retirement on 8% yield and that’s not going to work out well.
    Our state has high income tax so dividend isn’t the best investment for us. Maybe we should move 5 miles north…
    Nice analysis.

    Reply
  • August 29, 2016 at 8:08 AM
    Permalink

    I love dividend growth investing. My dividends are on track to exceed my expenses by 2018.

    I have noticed that people either immediately understand the concept, or they just don’t. It makes sense to me that if you buy a company with a track record of dividend growth, at an attractive price, and you hold on to it patiently, good things can happen to you. Rising earnings lead to rising dividends and maybe even rising share prices. Mr Market can go crazy and I will be fine as long as the business is doing well, and paying me to hold it. Analyzing dividend growth stocks, forces me to think like an owner.

    I agree 100% that you do have to be patient in order to reap the maximum rewards with DGI. As for the yield/growth trade off – I hold all three types of DGI stocks. I am very very cautious with higher yielders too.

    As for dividend kings – these are companies that have managed to raise dividends every single year for at least 50 years in a row. Not bad 😉

    DGI

    Reply
  • September 1, 2016 at 10:53 AM
    Permalink

    I hold one single company for dividend growth 🙂 all the rest is in the indexes. So far I can’t complain, they just increased their dividend last week another 10% !

    Reply
  • September 5, 2016 at 8:22 AM
    Permalink

    I began my dividend experiment this summer with one REIT stock to see what it was like. Personally, I can only learn so much by reading. Seeing what it is like is incredibly helpful to me. I don’t have a 401K, but I also live in a place with a high income tax. I’m still figuring out where that will lead my investments.

    Reply
  • September 8, 2016 at 4:55 AM
    Permalink

    Great post Mr. Tako! I just found your blog but I’m definitely gonna be a regular reader. 50k in yearly dividends is pretty impressive. I suppose we are talking about an over 1 million USD portfolio here (only the stock part). I’m in my early 30s and just started this year to build up my early retirement portfolio where dividend income would also be a big factor. My yearly aim is EUR 700 from dividends, so still need some time to catch up:) I’m hoping to be around this level in about 15-17 years.
    Maybe I’ll find a post like that at your blog; it would be good to read about how you started.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *